To Cut Defense Costs, In At Least One Area, Pentagon Should Cut Competition

31/03/2015 16:39

To Cut Defense Costs, In At Least One Area, Pentagon Should Cut Competition


Last week Representatives Thornberry (R-TX) and Smith (D-WA), the Chairman and Ranking Member of the House Armed Services Committee, unveiled a bipartisan proposal to reform the defense acquisition process. This proposal acknowledges the fact that there is no “silver bullet” for acquisition reform and instead proposes a number of relatively small changes to the existing system rather than a complete overhaul. Forbes reports.

One specific change proposed by Thornberry and Smith, however, may seem counterintuitive to many. They propose striking the requirement for DoD to use competitive prototyping in acquisitions. Competitive prototyping is a process by which DoD contracts with two or more companies to build working prototypes of a weapon system before selecting one (or more) for production. Eliminating this requirement will reduce opportunities for competition—which may at first seem counterproductive to cutting costs. But I think they are right.

The requirement to use competitive prototyping was a key provision of the 2009 acquisition reform legislation, known as WSARA (Weapon Systems Acquisition Reform Act). An overall theme in this previous attempt at acquisition reform was to create more opportunities for competition. Not only did WSARA require competitive prototyping, it also required the Department of Defense to use acquisition strategies that “ensure competition, or the option of competition, at both the prime contract level and the subcontract level.” But in my view, WSARA went too far and failed to recognize that a one-size-fits-all approach to competition is not in the best interests of DoD or the taxpayer.

To be clear, I’m not against competition in defense acquisitions. If used appropriately, competition can be a powerful force to drive down costs, spur innovation, and improve the performance of weapon systems. And competition certainly works in many areas, particularly when DoD is buying commercial or commercially-derived systems. But in a blind quest to increase competition, DoD and Congress have, in some instances, attempted to artificially create competition where it does not naturally exist and have driven up acquisition costs in the process.

How can this be true? First, the U.S. defense industry is not a traditional free market with many buyers and sellers and limited regulation. The defense industry can be more accurately characterized as a monopsony, with the U.S. government as the sole customer and chief regulator. There are few (if any) other buyers for many of the major weapon systems DoD procures, such as stealthy aircraft, aircraft carriers, nuclear-powered submarines, and specialized communications and electronics equipment. When other potential customers for these systems exist, such as U.S. allies and partners, sales must still be approved through the U.S. government and tend to be much lower in quantity.

Additionally, in many sectors of the defense industry there are a limited number of vendors capable of producing the weapon systems DoD requires—just one or two primes in some sectors. In these situations, the barriers to entry for competitors can be high, and artificially creating competition requires a large and sustained investment by DoD.

As the only customer for many of the weapon systems it buys, DoD pays the full development cost for these systems through cost reimbursable contracts or higher fees on fixed-priced contracts. When competitive prototyping is used, DoD pays the development costs for two or more contractors to develop similar systems. Once development work is complete, DoD usually selects a single vendor for production, effectively granting the winner a monopoly for future procurements of the same system.

If DoD instead decides to keep competition alive throughout production, it can split the award between competing contractors to keep two production lines running in parallel. A split award, however, means that neither contractor will receive the full order. Thus the cost of each unit will not decline as much as it would if one company were building all of the units.  This effect, known as the learning curve, has long been recognized and empirically observed.

Proponents of competition argue that the additional costs from redundant development work and reduced learning can be offset by the competitive pressure among contractors to drive down prices. But there is scant evidence to support this assumption for defense acquisitions. Historical data for acquisition programs only reveals what happened when dual sourcing was used. To calculate the savings from competition, one also needs to know the counterfactual—what would have happened had dual sourcing not been used in those same programs. Since historical analysis cannot produce data for a counterfactual, analysts often just assume what the costs would have been without competition. Their historical analysis is, therefore, based on nothing more than assumptions about a counterfactual.

In a 2012 paper, I proposed a game theory approach to model how contractors would be incentivized to bid under various forms of competition. Using this approach, I found that the way a competition is structured can be a determining factor in whether competitive pressure is sufficient to produce real savings. More specifically, I identified conditions in which the structure of the competition could actually incentivize contractors to bid higher and drive up costs—a finding I admit is strongly counterintuitive to many.

Without going into the gory details, which you can read here, the ability of competition and competitive prototyping to reduce costs depends on the type of weapon system being procured and the way a competition is structured. If the development costs of a weapon system are a large share of the total acquisition cost, the learning curve is steep, and small procurement quantities are planned, competition tends to be less effective. Therefore, it does not make sense to have a blanket policy requiring competition for all acquisitions by default. Of course acquisition costs are not the only factor to consider; DoD must also consider the effect of competition on long-term operation and maintenance costs, the industrial base, and innovation.

Competition certainly has an intuitive appeal as a way to drive down costs in defense acquisitions, but it is not always the most effective approach. Representatives Thornberry and Smith are on the right track in their acquisition reform efforts. Developing an acquisition strategy tailored to the unique circumstances of each program is critical to keeping costs affordable. And a key part of any acquisition strategy is a thoughtful analysis of if and when to use competition and competitive prototyping. Competition, while useful in many circumstances, is not a silver bullet for acquisition reform. It’s time we stop pretending that it is.


In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the editor by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.

Newsfeed

Today, 14:41 Ameriabank named the Best Bank in Armenia for 2024 by Global Finance magazine 28/03/2024 14:02 IoT Lab opens at National Polytechnic University of Armenia 26/03/2024 16:58 “START+”: “Kinodaran” without subscription fee, 10 GB internet, 1000 minutes and favorite apps without any limits 25/03/2024 16:14 Change in Viva-MTS company name and General Terms of Provisioning Services 22/03/2024 17:24 Marzes remain in the focus of attention of Viva-MTS: New service center opened in Tchambarak 21/03/2024 14:12 In 2023, the SME Loan Portfolio of Ameriabank Reported More Than 30% Growth 19/03/2024 10:20 Mikael Vardanyan donated 117 mln drams for garbage trucks and 230 waste bins for Masis community 14/03/2024 18:12 New technologies at the core of rural infrastructure development 13/03/2024 16:32 The number of Team mobile subscribers is over 1 million 13/03/2024 13:01 “RED”: fixed and mobile services in one package for customers valuing convenience and quality 11/03/2024 14:51 Global Finance Recognizes Ameriabank's Leadership in Sustainable Finance in Armenia 06/03/2024 14:07 Byblos Bank Armenia named CaseKey title sponsor again 05/03/2024 13:36 Doing Digital Forum Returns Featuring Brett King as Keynote Speaker 01/03/2024 18:42 "The Innovator's Dilemma": Byblos Bank Armenia supports publication of Armenian edition 29/02/2024 16:45 “Personal Assistant” program changes popular mindset in regions 27/02/2024 18:12 Viva-MTS: 30-day internet-package for the many destinations within “VOYAGE” service 22/02/2024 17:53 The kindergarten of Armavir village is already being supplied with solar photovoltaic panels 19/02/2024 16:53 Viva-MTS, a company cultivating reading traditions 19/02/2024 12:48 Ameriabank set to join BOGG, a London Stock Exchange (LSE) listed financial group as a standalone entity 14/02/2024 14:53 Years of hard work and a sustainable approach to infrastructure development in regions 07/02/2024 14:49 Virtual PBX: Smart tool for corporate clients 02/02/2024 18:26 Viva-MTS named one of the ten most attractive employers 26/01/2024 18:15 Ameriabank is the Largest Taxpayer Among Armenian Banks 25/01/2024 17:03 Viva-MTS and “SOURCE” Foundation's “Personal Assistant” program is achieving the desired result in Syunik 24/01/2024 19:14 The shareholder of Viva-MTS has changed: The company will reach new achievements 23/01/2024 12:56 Byblos Bank Armenia to sponsor CaseKey team’s participation in Budapest’s CUBE 2024 22/01/2024 14:27 53% increase in Internet traffic in the Viva-MTS network. New Year's Eve and the first day compared to the same period last year 18/01/2024 18:30 “Viva University”: a long-term investment in youth empowerment 29/12/2023 15:49 Viva-MTS: investments that ensure sustainable development using innovative solutions 28/12/2023 14:46 The Christmas Miracle in Shirak Region - Ameriabank Santas Visited Children from Artsakh 22/12/2023 11:43 12 participants of “Get Started” program will explore the startup ecosystem 20/12/2023 20:38 Byblos Bank Armenia donates New Year gift funds to Soldier's Home 14/12/2023 15:51 Daily solutions for Viva-MTS clients based on artificial intelligence and deep neural networks 13/12/2023 16:24 How Ameriabank continued to deliver success amid the volatility of the global markets 13/12/2023 10:15 Mikael Vardanyan donated the maternity hospital of the Surb Grigor Lusavorich Medical Center the modern medical equipment amounting 116 million drams (Video) 11/12/2023 15:53 Viva-MTS: business for business. Virtual PBX has become an effective management tool for corporate subscribers 09/12/2023 20:46 “We rule out the return of citizens of the Republic of Artsakh to the jurisdiction of Azerbaijan”: Tհe appeal of the political and civil organizations of the Artsakh to the International community 08/12/2023 14:01 «Wi-Fi Calling». call through Wi-Fi network from Armenia or abroad in frames of the tariff plan 30/11/2023 15:25 Changes in the terms of provisioning “M2M Tracker Plus” package of services 28/11/2023 18:34 A new phase of the educational program “Viva University” has started 27/11/2023 10:56 Armen Avetisian, Viva-MTS General Director, had an open-door lecture at YSU 20/11/2023 16:40 Viva-MTS and “SOURCE” foundation will support four families in Syunik through the program “Personal Assistant” 17/11/2023 17:36 Ameriabank Named the Best Bank for Digital Solutions in Armenia for 2023 16/11/2023 19:43 Best offer: Postpaid “UNLIM” – unlimited Internet for only 4500 AMD 15/11/2023 09:19 Byblos Bank Armenia Celebrates Education at CaseKey 2023 Gala 06/11/2023 16:18 30 years on stage: The partnership between Viva-MTS and “Paros” Chamber Choir continues 01/11/2023 17:12 Thinking “green” is a lifestyle․ Viva-MTS and "My Forest Armenia" continue the environmental partnership 01/11/2023 11:47 Red Flag Alert for Genocide - Azerbaijan in Armenia 31/10/2023 16:12 Now more than 500 thousand Viva-MTS subscribers use the VoLTE service 28/10/2023 10:44 Five times more internet in MTS Russia network 24/10/2023 16:53 “Recharge+”: now for up to AMD 3000 20/10/2023 11:05 Amundi-Acba made the first direct investment in the equities of an Armenian company 18/10/2023 14:53 Viva-MTS is the General Partner of the State Award of Republic of Armenia for Global Contribution to Humanity through High-Tech 16/10/2023 14:46 “UNLIM” tariff plan also available for postpaid subscribers 13/10/2023 12:35 Solar energy in Viva-MTS mobile stations: saving resources and oxygen 04/10/2023 18:06 Technological support to farmers: Electric fences in the border village of Vahan 27/09/2023 10:25 Financial support in the amount of 123 million drams from Karen Vardanyan to the families having many children, evicted as a result of the 44-day war (Video) 18/09/2023 14:15 President Samvel Shahramanyan has appointed Artur Harutyunyan as State Minister 07/09/2023 23:24 Ex-Ambassador Mikayel Minasyan: “Will Armenia face a war or not?” 31/08/2023 18:28 Ex-Ambassador Mikayel Minasyan has provided an analysis of the Armenian issue 30/08/2023 19:30 S&P Upgrades Ameriabank to 'BB-', Outlook Stable 26/08/2023 13:52 Ex-Ambassador Mikayel Minasyan calls for unconditional consolidation to preserve national identity and save Stepanakert 26/08/2023 13:51 Ex-Ambassador Mikayel Minasyan: “The situation still has a diplomatic resolution” 25/08/2023 12:29 Freedom Broker Introduces Full Brokerage Services for Individuals, Pioneering the Market in Armenia 15/08/2023 12:36 Ameriabank Wins in 3 Nominations of Global Finance World’s Best Digital Bank Awards 2023 01/08/2023 13:55 «Viva University»: Starting inception for university students 01/08/2023 09:57 “I do not know how to interpret the persecution of talented and creative people who have served Armenia all their lives” Defender of Armen and Sergey Smbatyans 19/07/2023 16:16 Amundi-Acba made a huge investment in the RA economy 19/07/2023 10:30 Electric Fences are a new replacement for scarecrows: modern technologies made available to villages by Viva-MTS 14/07/2023 11:39 Viva-MTS presents a podcast series on a variety of themes 13/07/2023 16:45 20,000 trees were mulched in Lori with the support of Viva-MTS Partnership to increase forest cover in Armenia 11/07/2023 11:42 A modern infrastructure system has been launched in border village of Koti 04/07/2023 18:39 Ameriabank Receives 4 Sustainable Finance Awards from Global Finance 01/07/2023 10:52 Viva-MTS turns 18: The best is yet to come 30/06/2023 20:18 Shell brand is already in Armenia. The first fuel stations were put into operation 29/06/2023 15:51 Moody's changes Ameriabank's outlook to stable; affirms Ba3 rating 28/06/2023 16:00 The latest volume of the book series "The Armenians of the World” " is dedicated to Armenian philanthropists of the world 27/06/2023 16:22 Mobile “Electric fences” in Yeghegis community have become an “obstacle” for bears 22/06/2023 13:16 Viva-MTS: Harmless interaction between "Electric Fences" and bears 22/06/2023 11:35 Governor of the State of Kansas Laura Kelly visited Tsitsernakaberd memorial 22/06/2023 10:57 Flynas started operating flights on the route Riyadh-Yerevan-Riyadh 16/06/2023 11:42 MyInvest. Ameriabank has Launched an Online Investment Platform 15/06/2023 13:04 Four projects of infrastructure development in border village Koghb 13/06/2023 15:36 Practical business skills in focus of CaseKey 2023–Byblos Bank Armenia partnership 12/06/2023 12:03 International experience and new football skills: Milan Academy Junior Camp wraps up in Yerevan 09/06/2023 13:55 Viva-MTS’ digital B2B services show steady growth 06/06/2023 12:33 Viva-MTS expands and strengthens the entire mobile infrastructure along with the development of the 5G network 05/06/2023 11:31 Partnership for Environmental Protection and Community Development 03/06/2023 11:56 15 schoolchildren face Gabriel Sargissian in open-air simultaneous display (Video) 02/06/2023 15:53 Team Telecom Armenia is undertaking its initial public offering (IPO) 01/06/2023 10:43 We hope that some of these Armenian children will become professional football players. Claudio Zola 01/06/2023 10:18 On the occasion of June 1st Karen Vardanyan provided 115 million drams to the parentless children of Yerevan 31/05/2023 19:15 Team Group of Companies has acquired 30% of Georgian SkyTel 29/05/2023 13:34 Fly Arna launches new direct flights connecting Yerevan to Kuwait 25/05/2023 14:33 Regional Call Center of Viva-MTS opens in Vanadzor 23/05/2023 17:48 15 YSU students will receive Byblos Bank Armenia scholarships and tuition reimbursement 23/05/2023 11:49 “Unlim”: New prepaid tariff plan by Viva-MTS 17/05/2023 15:37 “The path to creating this brandy was an endless aspiration to excellence for us, and I feel that we succeeded” - Olivier Chapt 17/05/2023 14:17 Border village Berdavan is almost completely illuminated 03/05/2023 14:02 The second batch of electric fences has been introduced in Vayots Dzor