The Paternalism of ‘Preparing’ Armenians for Peace: Aram Hamparian

20/02/2020 17:15

The Paternalism of ‘Preparing’ Armenians for Peace: Aram Hamparian


Executive Director of the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) Aram Hamparian referred in an extended article to the preparation of peoples of Armenia and Azerbaijan to peace.

The full article published in Asbarez is below:

Armenians don’t need to be “prepared” for Artsakh peace.

The unbridled arrogance of those who say we do is stunning.

As if we were children, unaware of our own best interests.

And that those “preparing” us had our best interests at heart.

Spare us the paternalism.

We know our history – its trials, tragedies, and triumphs.

And we know the long history – the lies and betrayals – of the global interests who, today, once again, claim for themselves the right to “prepare” us for our own future.

To ever engage on such condescending terms would be to disrespect ourselves.

To accept such paternalism would represent an existential surrender of the worst sort, a shameful self-identification of Armenians – by Armenians – as the objects of Armenian history.

That we will never do.

We are the rightful subjects – the determined drivers – of our destiny.

That being said, we remain open to reason.

If there are arguments to be made for particular Artsakh proposals, they should be presented and debated respectfully, on their merits.

Supporters of the Madrid Principles, for example, should make their case – citing relevant precedents, offering fact-based analyses, and modeling likely long-term outcomes – not using ad hominem attacks or seeking to infantilize the other side.

For our part, the ANCA has presented a detailed case against the Madrid Principles as a deeply flawed and ultimately counter-productive plan that sets back the cause of peace and raises the risks of renewed war. We hold that they are “profoundly asymmetrical, demanding upfront, strategic, and irrevocable concessions of land and security from Artsakh in return for only vague, deferred, and reversible promises regarding status from Azerbaijan.” As an alternative, we propose that the OSCE Minsk Group help develop “a new, democracy and self-determination driven approach that addresses – on a horizontal basis and in a package-based format – outstanding status and security issues between the republics of Artsakh and Azerbaijan,” and that Artsakh be restored as a direct stakeholder and full participant in all talks regarding its future.

Here in Washington, it’s painfully clear, in the context of all that has transpired, that Azerbaijan’s allies see the phrase “preparing populations for peace” as a clever way to advance an anti-Artsakh agenda without coming across as too overtly pro-Baku.

In practice, here’s what their “preparations” will really amount to, in terms of actual U.S. policy:

  • The State Department conducting robust public diplomacy and debate about Artsakh concessions in Armenia’s open media environment and free civil society, while walking on eggshells in authoritarian Azerbaijan, meticulously avoiding any utterance that might trigger Ilham Aliyev or his minions.
     
  • The State Department openly demanding upfront, strategic, and irrevocable land and security concessions from the Armenian side, while speaking in only the vaguest of terms about the promises Azerbaijan could potentially make about what it might one day possibly concede.
     
  • The State Department fostering the false impression that attacks across the line of contact are equally the fault of the Armenian and Azerbaijani sides, when all serious observers know that it is Baku that seeks to disrupt the status quo.
     
  • The State Department setting, as the Armenian side’s upper limit for the peace process, a return to Artsakh’s status quo ante (autonomy under Azerbaijani sovereignty).
     
  • The State Department crossing every Armenian redline, while carefully respecting each and every Azerbaijani sensitivity.
     
  • The State Department artificially equating Azerbaijan’s corrupt, authoritarian petro-monarchy with Armenia’s and Artsakh’s democratic governments.
     
  • The State Department relentlessly lecturing Armenians about what they must surrender, with no corresponding message to Azerbaijan regarding what it needs to cede.
     
  • The State Department putting all Armenian equities and interests on the bargaining table, while striving mightily to keep any mention of a free Artsakhoutside the scope of the talks.
     
  • The State Department equating the fundamentally American ideals of freedom from foreign rule and democratic self-governance (core tenets of the U.S. Declaration of Independence) with Stalin’s arbitrary and evil post-WWI divide-and-conquer territorial and demographic manipulations in the Caucasus.

No thank you.

Keep your condescension. We’ll keep Artsakh.


In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the editor by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.

Newsfeed

Today, 19:57 Another patient dies in Armenia from Covid-19 Today, 17:46 Russian scientists ready to develop coronavirus cure from survivors’ blood in 30 days Today, 16:32 Security Council Secretary holds phone conversation with CSTO Secretary General Today, 15:42 Number of Coronavirus Cases in Georgia Increases to 115 Today, 15:31 Arayik Harutyunyan says ready to form coalition with forces accepting that Artsakh is Armenia Today, 15:19 The fact of wounding of two Armenian servicemen and 14-year old resident of Voskevan very concerning: CSTO Secretary General Today, 14:29 Five political forces to be represented in Nagorno-Karabakh NA Today, 14:23 Gazprom Armenia to apply for raising gas tariffs for consumers from July 2020 Today, 14:05 Second round of elections to be conducted in Artsakh Today, 13:42 Comet five times the size of Jupiter is set to light up the night skies in April - and it could be brighter than Venus Today, 12:33 Coronavirus cases in Russia surpass 2,700 Today, 11:57 Over 750,000 COVID-19 cases, more than 36,000 deaths confirmed worldwide — WHO Today, 11:35 Yerevan metro is closed Today, 11:00 Armenia records 571 confirmed coronavirus cases Today, 10:47 Prince of Monaco recovers from coronavirus Today, 10:14 Public transport to stop working from April 1-12 Today, 10:05 Tighter restrictions enter into force, special checkpoints to control the move of the people and transportation means 31/03/2020 23:03 Armenia’s NA adopts controversial bill 31/03/2020 22:54 OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs not to accept results of Artsakh elections: statement 31/03/2020 21:29 Armenia’s FM, U.S. Acting Assistant Secretary discuss situation at Armenian-Azerbaijani border 31/03/2020 21:15 CSTO Secretary General expresses concern over recent incident at Armenian-Azerbaijani border 31/03/2020 19:36 Autopsy of person died from coronavirus not to be conducted: NA adopts corresponding law 31/03/2020 19:19 Armenia’s NA passes the bill on fixing phone calls of coronavirus infected people in the first reading at extraordinary session 31/03/2020 18:34 Yerevan tops the list of coronavirus-hit regions in Armenia, followed by Ararat and Kotayk 31/03/2020 17:08 Armenia discusses opportunity of producing own tests: Commandant 31/03/2020 16:57 Viva-MTS’ prepaid cards available in all “Press Stand” kiosks 31/03/2020 16:38 Commandant Tigran Avinyan hopes Armenia will return to normal life in mid-April 31/03/2020 16:31 Restrictions to be tightened: Armenia’s Commandant 31/03/2020 16:25 If not government restrictions 89% of Armenia’s population would have been infected: Tigran Avinyan 31/03/2020 15:53 Number of recovered from Covid-19 in Armenia reaches 31 31/03/2020 15:43 90 coronavirus infected in Armenia have pneumonia, condition of 30 assessed as grave: PM 31/03/2020 15:34 Armenia’s PM: Quarantine regime in Armenia extended for another 10 days 31/03/2020 15:07 Commandant’s decision on restricting entries and exists from Charentsavan community annulled 31/03/2020 14:58 Armenia’s government offers Russia to start new talks over gas price reduction: Deputy PM Mher Grigoryan applies to Miller 31/03/2020 14:10 Russians to be fined up to $3,800 for breaking coronavirus quarantine 31/03/2020 14:04 Two cases of coronavirus recorded in Armenia’s Tavush 31/03/2020 13:21 Number of coronavirus infected in Armenia increases to 532 31/03/2020 12:41 Van Gogh painting stolen from museum shuttered by Covid-19 pandemic: CNN 31/03/2020 12:07 Armenia to get 100 respiratory devices and 60 thousand tests soon 31/03/2020 11:36 Armenia’s MFA: Turkey's attempts to act as an international guardian of human rights are more than bankrupted in the light of its constant violations of the rights of peoples 31/03/2020 11:21 Armenian child wounded by Azerbaijani side stable, does not need second surgery 31/03/2020 10:58 Armenian PM’s visit to Gyumri postponed 31/03/2020 10:23 Presidential, parliamentary elections kick off in Artsakh 31/03/2020 10:14 Armenian grandmaster Levon Aronian’s wife Arianne Caoili dies 30/03/2020 23:20 Unprovoked ceasefire violation has no justification: Armenia’s MFA on military incident at Armenian-Azerbaijani border 30/03/2020 23:02 Life of wounded servicemen not in danger: DM spokesperson 30/03/2020 22:35 Condition of child wounded by Azerbaijani side stable grave 30/03/2020 21:39 Azerbaijani side makes subversive infiltration attempt, wounds Armenian servicemen 30/03/2020 21:24 Azerbaijani side shots and wounds a school-age child in Armenia’s Voskevan community 30/03/2020 17:05 Number of coronavirus cases in Germany up by 4,700 over past day 30/03/2020 16:46 Coronavirus most active at about 4 degrees Celsius, scientists say 30/03/2020 16:14 European Commission to allocate 140 million Euros to Eastern Partnership countries to combat social-economic consequences of coronavirus 30/03/2020 15:04 Russia's coronavirus cases rise to 1,836 in 24 hours 30/03/2020 14:47 Statistics of infected to influence the decision on lifting movement restrictions or not 30/03/2020 14:18 Armenia’s deputy PM: Gas prices will globally change 30/03/2020 13:51 Number of coronavirus-infected soldiers reach 6, no need to worry: DM 30/03/2020 12:58 One of new 58 confirmed coronaviruses cases recorded in the army 30/03/2020 12:46 Artsakh President sends condolences on death of French politician Patrick Devedjian 30/03/2020 12:42 Armenia’s government approves measure neutralizing impact of coronavirus on economy 30/03/2020 12:16 Tens of soldiers return to service after isolation and self-isolation: DM 30/03/2020 12:04 53 new coronavirus cases recorded in Armenia making total number of infected 482 30/03/2020 11:38 Number of Coronavirus Cases in Georgia Increases to 97 30/03/2020 11:20 Armenia’s government to convene extraordinary sitting today 30/03/2020 11:13 Russia restricts border entries amid pandemic 30/03/2020 10:47 Artsakh Republic to elect new president and parliament on March 31 29/03/2020 18:53 Nikol Pashinyan: “The passing of Patrick Devedjyan is an irreparable loss for Armenian-French friendship” 29/03/2020 18:50 Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan offers condolences on passing of Krzysztof Penderetsky 29/03/2020 15:29 14 employees of Armenia's Center for Control and Prevention of Diseases test positive for coronavirus 29/03/2020 12:22 Former French Minister of Armenian decent Patrick Devedjian dies of coronavirus: AFP 29/03/2020 11:17 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia reach 424 29/03/2020 08:03 Two people die from coronavirus in Armenia, making total number of deaths 3 28/03/2020 21:27 New restrictions by Russian government not to affect Armenian cargo transportation: PM 28/03/2020 21:17 35 new cases of coronavirus recorded in Armenia, making total number of infected 407 28/03/2020 19:50 Condition of two persons with coronavirus assessed extremely grave 28/03/2020 14:54 1,889 citizens subjected to administrative responsibility for violating self-isolation conditions: deputy police chief 28/03/2020 13:01 Coronavirus cradle Wuhan partly reopens after lockdown 28/03/2020 12:10 Coronavirus cases in Russia rise to over 1,000 in past 24 hours 28/03/2020 11:34 Armenia’s boxing team records coronavirus cases 28/03/2020 10:45 7 anti-Covid vaccine prototypes developed by Russia’s Medical Biological Agency 28/03/2020 10:24 Coronavirus: More than 900 deaths in a day in Italy 28/03/2020 10:04 Number of confirmed coronavirus cases in Armenia grow to 372 28/03/2020 00:52 U.S. to provide $1.1 million to Armenia for the fight against COVID-19 27/03/2020 19:39 Elect the one who can best provide for your security, the one who is able to take the hardest test: Serzh Sargsyan addresses to Artsakh people 27/03/2020 17:34 Sebastian Coe: 2021 World Athletics Championships may be rescheduled like Olympics 27/03/2020 15:57 Armenian serviceman wounded from fire opened by Azerbaijani side 27/03/2020 15:30 Coronavirus cases in Russia rise to over 1,000 in past 24 hours 27/03/2020 15:30 Britain's PM has tested positive for coronavirus 27/03/2020 15:15 Viva-MTS supports the first Armenian university online education platform developed by the Polytechnic University 27/03/2020 13:53 Number of servicemen infected with coronavirus in Armenia reaches 5: DM spokesperson 27/03/2020 13:42 Gazprom Armenia will not cut gas supply to consumers not having paid for it 27/03/2020 13:11 Coronavirus: South Africa begins three-week lockdown 27/03/2020 12:16 Two-month-old baby and mother infected with COVID-19 in Armenia: minister 27/03/2020 12:07 28 patients recover from COVID-19 in Armenia 27/03/2020 11:27 Armenian, Georgian PMs discuss situation over COVID-19 in the two countries 27/03/2020 10:59 G20 to inject $5 trillion into global economy to fight coronavirus consequences 27/03/2020 10:36 Coronavirus: US overtakes China with most cases 27/03/2020 10:07 Number of confirmed coronavirus cases in Armenia grow to 329 26/03/2020 18:14 First patient, 72, dies from coronavirus in Armenia 26/03/2020 16:55 Number of coronavirus cases in Russia grows to 840 over past day 26/03/2020 15:42 President Sahakyan met with representatives of the Artsakh Republic National Assembly political parties supporting the authorities