Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions

01/07/2019 15:17

Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions has published an extended article about reforms in Armenia's justice system and vetting to be introduced in the sector.

The full article is bellow:

As Armenia’s new government wrestles with how to move past a quarter-century of ill-governance and unaccountability, a popular international legal concept has become a buzzword: transitional justice.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has regularly deployed the term to describe his vision of reforming the judicial system. On May 24, parliament hosted public hearings to discuss the scope and applicability of transitional justice.

For advocates of transitional justice, the concept offers a means of creating a clean slate upon which to craft a better and more legitimate system of governance. It also may offer a way to reform the country’s institutions.

That struggle has been brought to the fore in recent battles between Pashinyan and the judicial system that have seen the prime minister attack senior judges as products of the former government.

But there remain questions over how the concept might be applied in Armenia. Long-time advocates of transitional justice argue that the proposed measures are too little, too late.

The concept can be a slippery one. The International Center for Transitional Justice, or ICTJ, a New York-based organization promoting the concept, says on its website that the phrase “refers to the ways countries emerging from periods of conflict and repression address large-scale or systematic human rights violations so numerous and so serious that the normal justice system will not be able to provide an adequate response.” It has been used in contexts like South Africa’s post-apartheid Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the lustration processes of security services in former Warsaw Pact states.

Ruben Carranza, a senior ICTJ expert, has been working with Armenia’s new authorities since shortly after they came to power last spring. Transitional justice in Armenia “can build the foundation for accountability and sustain it beyond the initial period of euphoria,” he said last year.

What that lofty aims can mean in practice in Armenia has remained unclear, and the authorities have yet to propose any specific legislation. But lawmakers are drafting on a working paper that will guide the process, said Maria Karapetyan, a member of parliament from the ruling coalition and a leading figure in the push for transitional justice, told Eurasianet.

One potential subject for transitional justice could be the highly contested politics of the 1990s.

“We cannot afford to reopen all the election ballots since 1991 to know if the elections were truly stolen,” Karapetyan said.

But Karapetyan said she envisions the process taking the form of a “memory commission” of sorts.

“Because we are dealing with competing narratives,” she said.

Other targets could be non-combat deaths in the military (259 in the period between 2010 and 2016, alone) and illegal confiscations of property by the government. The most prominent example of the latter is the forced displacement of hundreds of residents living in central Yerevan to clear space for the construction of the showcase Northern Avenue project.

The primary goal, Karapetyan said, “is the restoration of rights that have been violated en masse.”

What that restoration would entail is still under consideration, though some form of government payout and possibly civil forfeiture are on the table, she said.

There is one area that transitional justice won’t touch, she said: lustration of the security services.

“Lustration might have made sense when we were transitioning out of the Soviet Union and into an independent Armenia. But we don’t have that sort of a rupture,” Karapetyan said.

Parliament is expected to take the lead rather than the government, primarily with an eye to ensuring the success of Pashinyan’s so-called “economic revolution” and a favorable investment climate, Karapetyan said.

“For an economic revolution you need to have stability … Transitional justice assumes a certain shaking of the system, a certain instability,” she said. “You don’t want to scare away investors.”

While Pashinyan will not be involved in implementing a transitional justice system, he has embraced the idea. He has tended to frame it in narrower terms, however, as a means to reform the current judiciary, which is dominated by appointees of the previous order.

Pashinyan was especially incensed when a judge agreed to grant bail to Robert Kocharyan – a former president and the prime minister’s political nemesis – as he awaits trial on charges related to the breakup of violent protests in 2008. He cited transitional justice as a means of dealing with the problem.

Transitional justice, he said, was a “vital agenda for our country … to have a truly guaranteed independent judicial system in Armenia.”

Pashinyan called for “vetting” of current judges, a standard practice in transitional justice systems in other countries.

“The public should have complete information about their political connections and genealogy, property status, as well as about their personal and professional qualities manifested during the previous period,” he said.

A recent poll of Armenians’ trust in various institutions put the courts near the bottom of the list. That makes reform likely popular. And this could also have an institutional spillover effect.

“When the judiciary is independent, all of the other structures know that should they commit a violation or a crime, if it gets to court, they will be punished,” Karapetyan said.

Other moves taken by Pashinyan against the justice system have cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions. After Kocharyan was let out on bail, he called on supporters to protest outside court buildings, an act that was widely criticized as political interference in the justice system. And the newest appointee to the Constitutional Court is a longtime political ally of the incumbent authorities who employed an unorthodox power grab to try to become the head of the court.

Some supporters of vetting and transitional justice, though, think that the process has not gone nearly far enough.

“Either they don’t understand themselves as revolutionaries, or maybe they see themselves as ‘velvet revolutionaries,’” said Artur Sakunts, head of the Helsinki Citizens’ Assembly Vanadzor office, in an interview with Eurasianet. “We must have vetting of every single state body from the police, to the military, to the national security service, to the schools and universities,” he said.

Sakunts expressed concern the process will not go deep enough.

“The body of law, the constitution, the structures built by and for authoritarianism cannot build a democracy,” he said.

Larisa Minasyan, director of Open Society Foundations-Armenia, told Eurasianet that the hearings held so far have been a good start but that they needed to be broadened, not only in scope but at the level of public engagement, as well. (OSF-Armenia has been supporting the process, including by bringing some of the transitional justice experts to Armenia.)

“In the past 15 years, the trust towards institutions, not only the judiciary, but all institutions, stands so low that any such process, whether it's vetting, or vetting and something more, would not restore public trust ... if it’s not a process built on education and consensus,” she said.

[Disclaimer: Eurasianet receives funding from the Open Society Foundations, among other donors. OSF is part of the Soros Foundations network. The Open Society Foundations-Armenia is a separate entity in the Soros network.]

Minasyan is adamant that transitional justice must be comprehensive and offer redress for the many violations of human rights that occurred under the previous government. Doing that is imperative, she said.

In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the editor by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.


Today, 11:33 The main obstacle to peace in the region is Azerbaijan: human rights advocate Today, 11:22 Azerbaijan stands in way of peace: ANCA Executive director Today, 10:50 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia grows by 289 in past 24 hours, 4 new deaths reported Today, 10:26 Four dead in Mi-8 helicopter crash in Russia’s Chukotka 25/05/2020 20:17 Arthur Vanetsyan says he will never publish data of period he worked as NSS director 25/05/2020 19:58 Arthur Vanetsyan neither refutes nor confirms Pashinyan’s instruction to propose transaction to Mikayel Minasyan 25/05/2020 19:28 Arthur Vanetsyan says he acted in sidelines of his official authorities 25/05/2020 17:31 Ararat Mirzoyan Has a Telephone Talk with OSCE PA President George Tsereteli 25/05/2020 16:57 Artsakh president Arayik Harutyunyan sign cooperation memorandum with Samvel Babayan 25/05/2020 16:22 Nine children, 6 employees of Mary Izmirlyan children’s house test positive for coronavirus 25/05/2020 16:04 Bright Armenia to continue working stronger, targeted: Mane Tandilyan 25/05/2020 15:51 Bright Armenia to advance its agenda despite pressures: Edmon Marukyan 25/05/2020 15:28 La Liga could resume with Betis-Sevilla behind closed doors derby on 11 June 25/05/2020 14:33 Coronavirus: Georgia Reports 1 New Case, 4 Recoveries 25/05/2020 13:58 France has lowest daily rise in new coronavirus cases and deaths since lockdown 25/05/2020 13:00 Russia's coronavirus infections pass 350,000 25/05/2020 12:17 34 confirmed coronavirus cases are recorded in Artsakh 25/05/2020 12:07 NSS again refutes information about resignation of director Eduard Martirosyan 25/05/2020 11:24 Armenia passes to obligatory mask-regime: people to be fined by 10,000 AMD for not having them 25/05/2020 11:10 First coronavirus-infected maternal death recorded in Armenia 25/05/2020 10:59 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia grows by 452 in past 24 hours, 12 new deaths reported 24/05/2020 10:54 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia grows by 359 in past 24 hours, reaching 6,661 23/05/2020 15:14 Gagik Khachatryan was deprived of the constitutional right to healthcare: report filed about the crime 23/05/2020 15:11 Azerbaija violates ceasefire regime 180 times during past week 23/05/2020 13:59 Tbilisi responds to Arsen Torosyan’s statement, describes it non-diplomatic 23/05/2020 13:24 Coronavirus in Georgia: 5 New Cases, 14 Recoveries 23/05/2020 12:53 Russia reaches coronavirus plateau, says watchdog chief 23/05/2020 12:17 Adversary attempts subversive intrusion, thrown back with casualties: Artsakh Defense Army 23/05/2020 12:01 Pakistan plane crash: 'All I could see was fire' 23/05/2020 11:29 Incident with Tigran Atanesyan’s family needs serious public attention: advocate 23/05/2020 10:52 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia grows by 374 in past 24 hours, reaching 6,302, number of deaths reaches 109 23/05/2020 10:39 Brazil overtakes Russia in number of coronavirus cases 22/05/2020 17:17 Armenia’s health minister agrees that restriction measures in Georgia organized better 22/05/2020 17:02 Armenia’s health minister warns about sorting of patients if tempo of spread of coronavirus remains unchanged 22/05/2020 16:49 PM ignores public demand of consolidation, deepens the existing gap: political analyst 22/05/2020 16:33 Arthur Vanetsyan presents three options of change of power in accordance with constitutional order 22/05/2020 16:13 Construction of a half-built home in Gomk, yet another achievement of the partnership 22/05/2020 15:39 Airbus A320 with more than 100 people onboard crashes in Pakistan 22/05/2020 14:04 Daily COVID-19 case growth in Russia stays under 10,000 for seven days in a row 22/05/2020 13:14 Mikayel Minasyan offers political majority to be on height of political responsibility and make necessary decisions: Khosrov Harutyunyan 22/05/2020 12:02 Coronavirus: UK arrivals could face £1,000 fines if they break quarantine 22/05/2020 11:37 Artsakh President Arayik Harutyunyan, Armenia’s PM Nikol Pashinyan meet in Artsakh 22/05/2020 11:11 Territorial Administration and Infrastructures Minister Suren Papikyan tests negative 22/05/2020 11:02 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia grows by 322 in past 24 hours, reaching 5,928, five new deaths reported 22/05/2020 10:43 Chechen leader Kadyrov transferred to Moscow with suspected coronavirus - source 21/05/2020 19:13 Arayik Harutyunyan assumes post of President of the Republic of Artsakh 21/05/2020 18:45 Newly-elect Artsakh President says about intention to move Artsakh’s parliament to Shushi 21/05/2020 18:05 Armenia’s PM arrives in Artsakh 21/05/2020 17:57 U.S. Ambassador: In Nagorno-Karabakh conflict the USA focuses on preparing populations to peace 21/05/2020 17:33 U.S. Ambassador: No date for resuming visa services yet 21/05/2020 17:15 Formation of new government already a public demand: expert 21/05/2020 17:08 USA to allocate additional $1 million assistance to Armenia to fight coronavirus pandemic 21/05/2020 16:33 Belavia to implement Barcelona-Minsk-Yerevan flights from June 2 21/05/2020 16:25 Artsakh NA’s Justice faction to make final position about its posture in upcoming days: faction head 21/05/2020 15:45 Constitutional changes expected in Artsakh: vice speaker of Artsakh NA 21/05/2020 15:30 Georgia not to Prolong State of Emergency, Nationwide Curfew 21/05/2020 15:16 Artsakh’s ruling parliamentary faction head says about readiness to cooperate with all political forces 21/05/2020 15:02 Armenia’s second president files new lawsuit against Armenia’s PM Nikol Pashinyan 21/05/2020 14:30 There are no irreplaceable people, there is a need to solve institutional issues: Tevan Poghosyan on ex-ambassador’s statement 21/05/2020 14:13 Azerbaijan’s war threats and military posturing have no impact on the ongoing democratic processes in Artsakh: Armenia’s MFA spokesperson 21/05/2020 14:03 Armenia’s Prime Minister departs for Artsakh 21/05/2020 13:41 Artificial crisis must be created and extraordinary parliamentary elections be conducted: political analyst to Minasyan’s call 21/05/2020 13:20 Amphan: Kolkata devastated as cyclone leaves trail of death 21/05/2020 12:33 Armenia’s health minister says 270 citizens under 18 and 23 pregnant women have COVID-19 21/05/2020 12:18 135 coronavirus patients are in grave condition, 63 in extremely grave: minister 21/05/2020 11:55 Asymptomatic patients not to be hospitalized from tomorrow: minister 21/05/2020 11:13 New anti-crisis government necessary to avoid humanitarian disaster in Armenia: Arthur Vanetsyan 21/05/2020 11:04 Minister Suren Papikyan still in self-isolation 21/05/2020 10:54 Armenia’s PM says the situation with coronavirus very serious, calls for stricter control 21/05/2020 10:34 Mikayel Minasyan breaks PM’s character with his arguments: political technologist 21/05/2020 10:13 335 new coronavirus cases in 24 hours: Armenia’s PM says situation is very serious 20/05/2020 20:00 NSS to get instruction to search for satans inside My Step after Mikayel Minasyan's post: political technologist 20/05/2020 17:39 Armenian side to initiate preventive measures immediately in case Azerbaijani drills contain any threat: deputy DM 20/05/2020 16:48 Coronavirus: Spain tightens mask rules for all older than five 20/05/2020 16:08 Six new coronavirus cases recorded in Armenia’s Gegharkunik province, making total number of infected 290 20/05/2020 15:53 Pashinyan is afraid of each opposition gathering like the Satan from garlic: Armen Ashotyan 20/05/2020 15:26 Six employees of restaurant sector protesting outside government building apprehended 20/05/2020 15:03 Unknown people steal few monuments to football players of legendary Ararat-73 20/05/2020 14:55 Serzh Sragsyan’s lawyer petitions to postpone the trial due to surging epidemic situation in Armenia 20/05/2020 14:00 Cambridge University: All lectures to be online-only until summer of 2021 20/05/2020 13:40 Employees of restaurant sector to hold discussions with Commandant’s Office 20/05/2020 13:21 Restaurant owners, employees gather outside government building, demand allowing them to work 20/05/2020 13:05 Twenty people from Adekvad unity taken to police 20/05/2020 12:20 Number of coronavirus recoveries exceeds new cases for first time in Russia 20/05/2020 11:24 Artsakh successfully tests combat drone (video) 20/05/2020 11:10 Criminal case filed into death of conscript in Artsakh 20/05/2020 11:03 Number of coronavirus cases in Armenia grows by 230 in past 24 hours, reaching 5,271, death toll increases to 94 20/05/2020 10:47 Soldier received fatal gunshot wound in yet unknown circumstances in Artsakh 19/05/2020 19:27 Armenia’s Civil Aviation Committee chairperson Tatevik Revazyan gives birth to a baby girl (photos) 19/05/2020 19:00 Viva-MTS integrates the “Lucky Carrot” platform to increase employee engagement, cooperation and productivity 19/05/2020 18:51 Armenia’s PM urges to treat coronavirus seriously, not to believe false and absurd information 19/05/2020 18:34 Pashinyan: Current dynamics of spread of COVID-19 may result in tens of deaths daily 19/05/2020 18:12 Armenian NA adopts bill: not having masks in open territory to be fined by 10,000 AMD 19/05/2020 17:42 Tourism sector is in lockout but it is possible to save it: Mekhak Apresyan 19/05/2020 16:23 IMF Executive Board approves $280 million emergency funding for Armenia 19/05/2020 16:02 Deputy prosecutor of Shirak province appointed head of NSS Investigative Department 19/05/2020 15:54 Number of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Armenia's Gegharkunik province reaches 284 19/05/2020 15:50 NSS Investigative Department head resigns 19/05/2020 15:40 Covid-19 patients with no symptoms will not be isolated, to be treated in home conditions 19/05/2020 14:48 Russian president: Uniform tariff on gas transit in the EAEU cannot be applied in the current level of integration