Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions

01/07/2019 15:17

Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions has published an extended article about reforms in Armenia's justice system and vetting to be introduced in the sector.

The full article is bellow:

As Armenia’s new government wrestles with how to move past a quarter-century of ill-governance and unaccountability, a popular international legal concept has become a buzzword: transitional justice.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has regularly deployed the term to describe his vision of reforming the judicial system. On May 24, parliament hosted public hearings to discuss the scope and applicability of transitional justice.

For advocates of transitional justice, the concept offers a means of creating a clean slate upon which to craft a better and more legitimate system of governance. It also may offer a way to reform the country’s institutions.

That struggle has been brought to the fore in recent battles between Pashinyan and the judicial system that have seen the prime minister attack senior judges as products of the former government.

But there remain questions over how the concept might be applied in Armenia. Long-time advocates of transitional justice argue that the proposed measures are too little, too late.

The concept can be a slippery one. The International Center for Transitional Justice, or ICTJ, a New York-based organization promoting the concept, says on its website that the phrase “refers to the ways countries emerging from periods of conflict and repression address large-scale or systematic human rights violations so numerous and so serious that the normal justice system will not be able to provide an adequate response.” It has been used in contexts like South Africa’s post-apartheid Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the lustration processes of security services in former Warsaw Pact states.

Ruben Carranza, a senior ICTJ expert, has been working with Armenia’s new authorities since shortly after they came to power last spring. Transitional justice in Armenia “can build the foundation for accountability and sustain it beyond the initial period of euphoria,” he said last year.

What that lofty aims can mean in practice in Armenia has remained unclear, and the authorities have yet to propose any specific legislation. But lawmakers are drafting on a working paper that will guide the process, said Maria Karapetyan, a member of parliament from the ruling coalition and a leading figure in the push for transitional justice, told Eurasianet.

One potential subject for transitional justice could be the highly contested politics of the 1990s.

“We cannot afford to reopen all the election ballots since 1991 to know if the elections were truly stolen,” Karapetyan said.

But Karapetyan said she envisions the process taking the form of a “memory commission” of sorts.

“Because we are dealing with competing narratives,” she said.

Other targets could be non-combat deaths in the military (259 in the period between 2010 and 2016, alone) and illegal confiscations of property by the government. The most prominent example of the latter is the forced displacement of hundreds of residents living in central Yerevan to clear space for the construction of the showcase Northern Avenue project.

The primary goal, Karapetyan said, “is the restoration of rights that have been violated en masse.”

What that restoration would entail is still under consideration, though some form of government payout and possibly civil forfeiture are on the table, she said.

There is one area that transitional justice won’t touch, she said: lustration of the security services.

“Lustration might have made sense when we were transitioning out of the Soviet Union and into an independent Armenia. But we don’t have that sort of a rupture,” Karapetyan said.

Parliament is expected to take the lead rather than the government, primarily with an eye to ensuring the success of Pashinyan’s so-called “economic revolution” and a favorable investment climate, Karapetyan said.

“For an economic revolution you need to have stability … Transitional justice assumes a certain shaking of the system, a certain instability,” she said. “You don’t want to scare away investors.”

While Pashinyan will not be involved in implementing a transitional justice system, he has embraced the idea. He has tended to frame it in narrower terms, however, as a means to reform the current judiciary, which is dominated by appointees of the previous order.

Pashinyan was especially incensed when a judge agreed to grant bail to Robert Kocharyan – a former president and the prime minister’s political nemesis – as he awaits trial on charges related to the breakup of violent protests in 2008. He cited transitional justice as a means of dealing with the problem.

Transitional justice, he said, was a “vital agenda for our country … to have a truly guaranteed independent judicial system in Armenia.”

Pashinyan called for “vetting” of current judges, a standard practice in transitional justice systems in other countries.

“The public should have complete information about their political connections and genealogy, property status, as well as about their personal and professional qualities manifested during the previous period,” he said.

A recent poll of Armenians’ trust in various institutions put the courts near the bottom of the list. That makes reform likely popular. And this could also have an institutional spillover effect.

“When the judiciary is independent, all of the other structures know that should they commit a violation or a crime, if it gets to court, they will be punished,” Karapetyan said.

Other moves taken by Pashinyan against the justice system have cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions. After Kocharyan was let out on bail, he called on supporters to protest outside court buildings, an act that was widely criticized as political interference in the justice system. And the newest appointee to the Constitutional Court is a longtime political ally of the incumbent authorities who employed an unorthodox power grab to try to become the head of the court.

Some supporters of vetting and transitional justice, though, think that the process has not gone nearly far enough.

“Either they don’t understand themselves as revolutionaries, or maybe they see themselves as ‘velvet revolutionaries,’” said Artur Sakunts, head of the Helsinki Citizens’ Assembly Vanadzor office, in an interview with Eurasianet. “We must have vetting of every single state body from the police, to the military, to the national security service, to the schools and universities,” he said.

Sakunts expressed concern the process will not go deep enough.

“The body of law, the constitution, the structures built by and for authoritarianism cannot build a democracy,” he said.

Larisa Minasyan, director of Open Society Foundations-Armenia, told Eurasianet that the hearings held so far have been a good start but that they needed to be broadened, not only in scope but at the level of public engagement, as well. (OSF-Armenia has been supporting the process, including by bringing some of the transitional justice experts to Armenia.)

“In the past 15 years, the trust towards institutions, not only the judiciary, but all institutions, stands so low that any such process, whether it's vetting, or vetting and something more, would not restore public trust ... if it’s not a process built on education and consensus,” she said.

[Disclaimer: Eurasianet receives funding from the Open Society Foundations, among other donors. OSF is part of the Soros Foundations network. The Open Society Foundations-Armenia is a separate entity in the Soros network.]

Minasyan is adamant that transitional justice must be comprehensive and offer redress for the many violations of human rights that occurred under the previous government. Doing that is imperative, she said.

In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the editor by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.


14/09/2019 14:04 Azerbaijan violates ceasefire regime over 95 times during past week 14/09/2019 13:56 Boy, 2,5, shows positive signs of improvement 14/09/2019 12:37 Issue of providing social assistance to needy, socially insecure families to be solved soon: minister 14/09/2019 11:41 Founder of Security Dream company released for bail: advocate 14/09/2019 11:20 Flash floods in south-eastern Spain kill at least five 14/09/2019 10:12 Saudi Arabia oil facilities ablaze after drone strikes 13/09/2019 18:00 Alex Chung to join Kim Kardashian West on a Panel at WCIT 2019 13/09/2019 17:30 Ucom Kicks Off Pre-Sales for the Latest iPhone 11, iPhone 11 Pro and iPhone 11 Pro Max Smartphones 13/09/2019 17:00 Newly appointed head of EU delegation to Armenia passes to work 13/09/2019 16:33 ARF-D representative sees solution to Amulsar issue via referendum 13/09/2019 16:27 What takes place is not a revolution but degradation and distortion: Arstvik Minasyan on economic revolution stated by PM 13/09/2019 15:49 Government’s initiative on bank secrecy to result in serious explosion: ARF-D representative 13/09/2019 14:59 'Hit them!': Duterte tells Filipinos to shoot corrupt officials, promises no prison time 13/09/2019 14:07 Macron pension reform: Paris paralysed by massive strike 13/09/2019 13:02 Without Armenia’s consent voiced position to remain just a position: Armenia’s MFA responds to Russia’s statement about granting status of observer to Azerbaijan in CSTO 13/09/2019 12:52 Ceasefire violations do not reach worrying levels: Defense Ministry spokesperson 13/09/2019 12:42 New body to be created at Armenia’s Defense Ministry to deal with social, health issues of servicemen, veterans, freedom-fighters 13/09/2019 12:38 Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs agree to Minsk Group co-chairs’ proposal to meet 13/09/2019 12:09 Servicemen Insurance Fund pays compensations to almost 370 families of killed and disabled servicemen 13/09/2019 11:22 Yerevan mayor Hayk Marutyan to be summoned to National Assembly 13/09/2019 11:03 Hurricane Dorian: Number of missing drops to 1,300 13/09/2019 10:31 NSS declines Davit Sanasaryan’s petition to stop criminal persecution against him 13/09/2019 10:22 Contract serviceman commits suicide in Armenia’s Tavush region 12/09/2019 20:31 Violation of bank secrecy big mistake: economist on government’s initiative 12/09/2019 19:47 Trial turned into show: ex-president’s son dissatisfied with court’s decision to publish ruling on September 17 12/09/2019 19:22 Court to announce decision over Kocharyan’s preventive measure on September 17 12/09/2019 18:41 «Five Years of Eurasian Economic Union» collector coin is issued 12/09/2019 17:00 Apple's new iPhones shift smartphone camera battleground to AI 12/09/2019 16:14 Macron ally Ferrand investigated over financial misconduct 12/09/2019 15:26 Most shameful criminal case in Armenia’s history: Kocharyan about his case 12/09/2019 14:39 CSTO doors open to all but decisions are made via consensus: CSTO acting secretary general 12/09/2019 14:04 Russia not against granting status of observer to Azerbaijan in CSTO: Russian official 12/09/2019 13:32 March 1 trial kicks off, ex-DM urges change of Kocharyan’s preventive measure 12/09/2019 13:24 Accusation against my father lack any murder, the accusation is empty: Levon Kocharyan 12/09/2019 13:08 Oxford top of global university rankings 12/09/2019 11:53 Water detected in atmosphere of potentially habitable super-Earth 12/09/2019 11:27 Restaurant to open at Karen Demirtchyan sport and concert complex 12/09/2019 11:07 Oil gains on hopes for U.S., China trade war thaw, lower crude stocks 12/09/2019 10:47 Another Family from Gyumri to Leave the Metal Container 12/09/2019 10:29 Trump delays tariff hikes on Chinese goods ahead of talks 11/09/2019 19:50 Vitaly Balasanyan receives second writ to show up for interrogation in the sidelines of March 1 criminal case 11/09/2019 17:29 Finding the truth is our mission: Armenia’s PM on Amulsar 11/09/2019 16:23 Body of serviceman of Russian 102d military base in Armenia’s Gyumri found in apartment 11/09/2019 16:15 U.S. President is to decide further policy over Iran: political analyst 11/09/2019 15:10 Government to allocate over 35 million AMD for celebrating Independence Day on September 21 11/09/2019 14:43 Brexit: Scottish judges rule Parliament suspension is unlawful 11/09/2019 14:06 Amulsar issue Armenia’s domestic affair: Russia’s ambassador 11/09/2019 14:00 Being in Russia does not mean having political asylum: Russia’s ambassador about Mihran Poghosyan 11/09/2019 13:49 Russia’s president should be expected to visit Armenia: Ambassador 11/09/2019 13:25 My Step faction lawmaker does not share Zhirayr Sefilyan’s viewpoint about snap parliamentary elections in Armenia in 2020 11/09/2019 13:15 People are free to express non-confidence to authorities in Amulsar issue, initiate referendum: lawmaker 11/09/2019 12:52 Iran says sacking of Bolton won't lead to talks with U.S. 11/09/2019 12:23 No grounds exist for snap parliamentary elections: My Step lawmaker 11/09/2019 12:13 Issues raised before should not be forgotten after becoming part of ruling power: My Step faction lawmaker on Amulsar exploitation 11/09/2019 11:42 U.S. Ambassador to Armenia pays tribute to the victims of September 11 terrorist attack 11/09/2019 11:28 Parliament backs legislative initiative relating to traffic security at first reading 11/09/2019 10:45 U.S. President Trump fires national security adviser John Bolton 11/09/2019 10:30 Arab nations condemn Netanyahu's West Bank annexation plan 10/09/2019 17:30 VivaCell-MTS’ experience as a means of professional orientation 10/09/2019 17:06 Lawmaker Arman Babajanyan to keep his mandate 10/09/2019 16:41 Armenia’s PM’s statement over Amulsar result of thorough discussions: My Step lawmaker 10/09/2019 16:22 No grounds not to trust government: My Step lawmaker on Amulsar issue 10/09/2019 16:07 My Step faction supports PM in Amulsar issue: Lawmaker 10/09/2019 15:55 Artsakh’s processed pomegranate produce to be exported to world market: Artsakh agriculture minister 10/09/2019 14:59 Over 800 buses necessary for eliminating public collapse in Yerevan 10/09/2019 14:30 Armenia undertakes response measure against Russia 10/09/2019 14:14 Armenia Wine’s Gold Victory at Grand International Wine Award MUNDUS VINI 10/09/2019 14:11 Sanitek trying to lay its problems on municipality: Yerevan mayor 10/09/2019 13:58 Afghan peace deal: Trump says Taliban talks are 'dead' 10/09/2019 13:13 Armenia not to allow Azerbaijan gain status of observer or partner of CSTO: Ruben Rubinyan 10/09/2019 12:39 Armenia purchases exclusive weapon from Russia: deputy FM 10/09/2019 12:12 Armenia acquires weapons from CSTO member states with affordable prices: deputy FM 10/09/2019 11:51 Azerbaijan lacks any weight in the CSTO: deputy FM 10/09/2019 11:13 Kim Kardashian West to Visit Armenia and Participate in WCIT 2019 10/09/2019 11:10 Armenia’s parliament adopts number of legislative initiatives 10/09/2019 10:55 Brexit: Parliament suspension begins as Johnson's election bid fails 10/09/2019 10:29 Zhamanak: Sasna Tsrer-Pashinyan meeting took place thanks to Amulsar issue 10/09/2019 10:15 Consistent fight against corruption results in saving 3,8 billion AMD by Armenia’s Labor and Social Affairs Ministry: PM 09/09/2019 17:34 2,5-year-old boy who fell from sixth floor in Yerevan comes into consciousness, recognizes parents: spokesperson 09/09/2019 16:55 New garbage trucks reach Yerevan, garbage removal issue nears to logical end: Armenia’s PM 09/09/2019 16:31 Brexit: Parliament suspension to go ahead later 09/09/2019 15:45 PM’s statement over Amulsar not against people’s interests: Lilit Makunts 09/09/2019 15:10 PM’s urge to open roads to Amulsar must be grounded: Edmon Marukyan 09/09/2019 14:59 My Step faction head unaware what Mr Sefilyan talks about 09/09/2019 14:17 Summer heat killed nearly 1,500 in France, officials say 09/09/2019 13:51 Roads to Amulsar mine will not open, this page is closed: Jermuk resident 09/09/2019 13:40 Babajanyan’s decision to leave Bright Armenia faction expected: Edmon Marukyan 09/09/2019 13:20 Amulsar exploitation to result in inevitable consequences: geologist 09/09/2019 12:28 Construction works in Amulsar not to launch earlier than April 2020 09/09/2019 12:15 Armenia’s Prosecutor’s General Office refrains from commenting on CC’s ruling over Kocharyan’s case 09/09/2019 12:03 Most probable time for exploitation of Amulsar first quarter of 2021: Armenia’s PM 09/09/2019 11:38 Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan urges Jermuk residents to open roads to Amulsar 09/09/2019 11:16 No legal grounding for banning exploitation of Amulsar mine exists now: Armenia’s PM 09/09/2019 11:02 Norway dogs die in mystery illness 09/09/2019 10:44 National Assembly starts works after long vacation 09/09/2019 10:30 Price growth in Armenia low and controllable: Armenia’s PM 09/09/2019 10:03 Candidate Davit Sargsyan wins at Stepanakert mayoral elections 08/09/2019 19:03 Disagreements with Armenia should not qualified as tragedy: Artsakh president 08/09/2019 18:45 Artsakh ex-DM Levon Mnatsakanyan to be glad to become member of Armenia’s NA’s investigative commission set up to study April 2016 war 08/09/2019 18:38 USA wants to see powerful and successful Armenia: George Kent