Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions

01/07/2019 15:17

Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions has published an extended article about reforms in Armenia's justice system and vetting to be introduced in the sector.

The full article is bellow:

As Armenia’s new government wrestles with how to move past a quarter-century of ill-governance and unaccountability, a popular international legal concept has become a buzzword: transitional justice.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has regularly deployed the term to describe his vision of reforming the judicial system. On May 24, parliament hosted public hearings to discuss the scope and applicability of transitional justice.

For advocates of transitional justice, the concept offers a means of creating a clean slate upon which to craft a better and more legitimate system of governance. It also may offer a way to reform the country’s institutions.

That struggle has been brought to the fore in recent battles between Pashinyan and the judicial system that have seen the prime minister attack senior judges as products of the former government.

But there remain questions over how the concept might be applied in Armenia. Long-time advocates of transitional justice argue that the proposed measures are too little, too late.

The concept can be a slippery one. The International Center for Transitional Justice, or ICTJ, a New York-based organization promoting the concept, says on its website that the phrase “refers to the ways countries emerging from periods of conflict and repression address large-scale or systematic human rights violations so numerous and so serious that the normal justice system will not be able to provide an adequate response.” It has been used in contexts like South Africa’s post-apartheid Truth and Reconciliation Commission and the lustration processes of security services in former Warsaw Pact states.

Ruben Carranza, a senior ICTJ expert, has been working with Armenia’s new authorities since shortly after they came to power last spring. Transitional justice in Armenia “can build the foundation for accountability and sustain it beyond the initial period of euphoria,” he said last year.

What that lofty aims can mean in practice in Armenia has remained unclear, and the authorities have yet to propose any specific legislation. But lawmakers are drafting on a working paper that will guide the process, said Maria Karapetyan, a member of parliament from the ruling coalition and a leading figure in the push for transitional justice, told Eurasianet.

One potential subject for transitional justice could be the highly contested politics of the 1990s.

“We cannot afford to reopen all the election ballots since 1991 to know if the elections were truly stolen,” Karapetyan said.

But Karapetyan said she envisions the process taking the form of a “memory commission” of sorts.

“Because we are dealing with competing narratives,” she said.

Other targets could be non-combat deaths in the military (259 in the period between 2010 and 2016, alone) and illegal confiscations of property by the government. The most prominent example of the latter is the forced displacement of hundreds of residents living in central Yerevan to clear space for the construction of the showcase Northern Avenue project.

The primary goal, Karapetyan said, “is the restoration of rights that have been violated en masse.”

What that restoration would entail is still under consideration, though some form of government payout and possibly civil forfeiture are on the table, she said.

There is one area that transitional justice won’t touch, she said: lustration of the security services.

“Lustration might have made sense when we were transitioning out of the Soviet Union and into an independent Armenia. But we don’t have that sort of a rupture,” Karapetyan said.

Parliament is expected to take the lead rather than the government, primarily with an eye to ensuring the success of Pashinyan’s so-called “economic revolution” and a favorable investment climate, Karapetyan said.

“For an economic revolution you need to have stability … Transitional justice assumes a certain shaking of the system, a certain instability,” she said. “You don’t want to scare away investors.”

While Pashinyan will not be involved in implementing a transitional justice system, he has embraced the idea. He has tended to frame it in narrower terms, however, as a means to reform the current judiciary, which is dominated by appointees of the previous order.

Pashinyan was especially incensed when a judge agreed to grant bail to Robert Kocharyan – a former president and the prime minister’s political nemesis – as he awaits trial on charges related to the breakup of violent protests in 2008. He cited transitional justice as a means of dealing with the problem.

Transitional justice, he said, was a “vital agenda for our country … to have a truly guaranteed independent judicial system in Armenia.”

Pashinyan called for “vetting” of current judges, a standard practice in transitional justice systems in other countries.

“The public should have complete information about their political connections and genealogy, property status, as well as about their personal and professional qualities manifested during the previous period,” he said.

A recent poll of Armenians’ trust in various institutions put the courts near the bottom of the list. That makes reform likely popular. And this could also have an institutional spillover effect.

“When the judiciary is independent, all of the other structures know that should they commit a violation or a crime, if it gets to court, they will be punished,” Karapetyan said.

Other moves taken by Pashinyan against the justice system have cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions. After Kocharyan was let out on bail, he called on supporters to protest outside court buildings, an act that was widely criticized as political interference in the justice system. And the newest appointee to the Constitutional Court is a longtime political ally of the incumbent authorities who employed an unorthodox power grab to try to become the head of the court.

Some supporters of vetting and transitional justice, though, think that the process has not gone nearly far enough.

“Either they don’t understand themselves as revolutionaries, or maybe they see themselves as ‘velvet revolutionaries,’” said Artur Sakunts, head of the Helsinki Citizens’ Assembly Vanadzor office, in an interview with Eurasianet. “We must have vetting of every single state body from the police, to the military, to the national security service, to the schools and universities,” he said.

Sakunts expressed concern the process will not go deep enough.

“The body of law, the constitution, the structures built by and for authoritarianism cannot build a democracy,” he said.

Larisa Minasyan, director of Open Society Foundations-Armenia, told Eurasianet that the hearings held so far have been a good start but that they needed to be broadened, not only in scope but at the level of public engagement, as well. (OSF-Armenia has been supporting the process, including by bringing some of the transitional justice experts to Armenia.)

“In the past 15 years, the trust towards institutions, not only the judiciary, but all institutions, stands so low that any such process, whether it's vetting, or vetting and something more, would not restore public trust ... if it’s not a process built on education and consensus,” she said.

[Disclaimer: Eurasianet receives funding from the Open Society Foundations, among other donors. OSF is part of the Soros Foundations network. The Open Society Foundations-Armenia is a separate entity in the Soros network.]

Minasyan is adamant that transitional justice must be comprehensive and offer redress for the many violations of human rights that occurred under the previous government. Doing that is imperative, she said.

In case you have found a mistake in the text, please send a message to the editor by selecting the mistake and pressing Ctrl-Enter.


19/07/2019 20:26 Kocharyan’s case usual case for me, CC chairman Hrayr Tovmasyan 19/07/2019 13:03 Artificial intelligence; blockchain; “green” technologies: WCIT 2019 will explore the most up-to-date topics 18/07/2019 11:16 CC chairman says he does not comment political statements 18/07/2019 11:09 Armenia’s PM refers to illegal tree-cutting, developments in Ijevan 17/07/2019 22:13 «This judiciary starting from Constitutional court to the rest, is not compatible with New Armenia». Nikol Pashinyan 17/07/2019 15:01 Office of judge Davit Grigoryan searched in sidelines of criminal case: SIS confirms information 17/07/2019 14:52 Armenian family, including children, 4 and 6 die in traffic accident in Russia’s Krasnodar 17/07/2019 14:44 Ucom Completes the Placement of AMD and USD Bonds 17/07/2019 13:14 Adversary shots at Armenia’s Yelpin community, damages roof of one of houses 17/07/2019 09:11 Armenia’s distinguished actor Rudolph Ghevodnyan passed away after a lasting illness 16/07/2019 22:32 Armenia’s second president’s defense team appeals to Court of Cassation 15/07/2019 13:27 Issues on opening workshop for reconstruction of parts of airplanes in Armenia discussed with investments: Tatevik Revazyan 15/07/2019 11:24 Four water trucks, 67 rescuers participated in fire extinguishing works in Tsitsernakaberd 12/07/2019 19:08 The gas tariff issue cannot last for long: Vice-PM 12/07/2019 12:32 Coordinated Work in Different Communities 12/07/2019 12:24 With new amendment USA not allowed to provide defense articles to Azerbaijan that could be used to shoot down civilian aircraft operating out of Stepanakert Airport 11/07/2019 14:10 Additional 25 billion AMD necessary for raising pensions in Armenia from 2020 11/07/2019 13:58 Tusk’s unbalanced statements must give Armenian authorities food for thought: expert 11/07/2019 13:39 Iranian boats 'tried to intercept British tanker' 10/07/2019 16:36 Power failure in Armenia may be caused by problems in Iran: deputy minister 10/07/2019 15:40 Power system failure caused by frequency fluctuations: deputy minister 10/07/2019 14:39 Metro passengers evacuated due to problems caused by blackout 10/07/2019 14:32 Widespread blackout registered in Yerevan from 12.30 p.m. 10/07/2019 14:24 Yerevan and Baku must display restraint and restore peace-promoting atmosphere: CoE chairman 10/07/2019 14:14 Armenia’s positive dynamics creates new opportunities for cooperation: Tusk 09/07/2019 18:26 International Republican Institute conducts another public opinion survey to learn people’s attitude toward state institutions and the church 09/07/2019 17:59 Karabakh conflict has only political solution: Tusk 08/07/2019 13:22 One dead, 10 injured in quake in southwestern Iran 08/07/2019 10:21 Three Armenian citizens suffered in traffic accident in Georgia transported to Armenia in ambulance, those in grave conditions via helicopter 06/07/2019 23:37 Armenia's ambassador to UK and Northern Ireland Arman Kirakosyan passed away 06/07/2019 18:07 Chairman of the Council of Europe Donald Tusk to arrive in Armenia 06/07/2019 18:01 Six people burnt alive, ten transported to hospital after major accident in Armenia’s Ararat region 05/07/2019 17:21 Nikol Pashinyan holds phone conversation with Vladimir Putin 05/07/2019 17:20 PM Pashinyan pays tribute to memory of Vietnam’s heroes and Hồ Chí Minh 05/07/2019 17:15 What Constitution says is obliging: Serzh Sargsyan 04/07/2019 21:01 No crisis in Constitutional Court of Armenia: CC chairman 04/07/2019 20:18 Day of Constitution not to be officially marked in Armenia 04/07/2019 12:55 Negotiations with Russia over gas price reduction continue: Garegin Baghramyan 04/07/2019 12:50 Ucom’s «2 Numbers in 1 SIM Card» Offer Available in the Service Centers of Russian Tele2 03/07/2019 18:59 Armenia’s deputy PM meets with President of Iran Hasan Rouhani 03/07/2019 15:30 Nikol Pashinyan holds phone conversation with Sooronbay Jeenbekov 03/07/2019 14:40 It is important for France to refrain from military-industrial cooperation with Azerbaijan: Armenia’s MFA 03/07/2019 14:20 Russian Security Council claims NATO plans “color revolution” in CSTO countries 03/07/2019 14:08 Scenario of one-sided concessions excluded: MFA spokesperson 02/07/2019 18:18 Armenia’s PM holds phone conversation with Kazakh president 02/07/2019 17:59 Ararat Mirzoyan Meets with President of House of Representatives of Uruguay Cecilia Bottino 02/07/2019 17:11 Manvel Grigoryan to undergo new judicial-medical expertise 02/07/2019 16:06 Manvel Grigoryan to remain in custody, court denies petition to release him 02/07/2019 13:17 Sevan Lake taken to annihilation: environmentalist 02/07/2019 13:07 Armenia’s PM holds phone conversation with president of Belarus 02/07/2019 12:02 Water volume given to water users reduces this year by 30 million cubic meters as compared with 2018 02/07/2019 10:51 Hong Kong protests: Carrie Lam condemns 'extreme use of violence' 01/07/2019 18:55 Unemployed residents of Alaverdi promised to be taken to work to Teghout but promise not kept 01/07/2019 15:33 Bug Bounty: e-Gov Hackathon Results Known 01/07/2019 15:17 Eurasianet: Pashinyan's moves against justice system cast doubt on the sincerity of his intentions 01/07/2019 14:48 Armenia’s Prosecutor General satisfied with Court of Appeal decision over Kocharyan’s case 01/07/2019 14:12 No information about more than 10 victims during March 1 events in Yerevan: Artur Davtyan 01/07/2019 13:08 Igor Grigoryan appointed head of Artsakh Investigation Committee 01/07/2019 11:37 Armenian humanitarian mission demines 34,693 sq. m. territory in Syria 01/07/2019 11:10 Hong Kong: Police and protesters clash on handover anniversary 01/07/2019 10:12 Armenia’s PM congratulates Armenian team on successful performance at European games 29/06/2019 16:31 Robert Kocharyan to continue being member of Board of Directors of Russian Systema corporation 29/06/2019 14:16 Azerbaijani side violates ceasefire over 90 times during the past week 29/06/2019 13:24 G20 summit: Trump and Xi agree to restart US-China trade talks 29/06/2019 12:06 Possibility of resumption of military actions very high: Arshavir Gharamyan 29/06/2019 11:51 OSCE CiO expresses full support to Karabakh conflict settlement efforts: statement 29/06/2019 11:11 Parliament of Cyprus ratifies EU-Armenia Comprehensive and Enhanced agreement 29/06/2019 10:40 Trump says he wants to 'shake hands' with North Korea's Kim at DMZ 28/06/2019 20:19 Security Council secretary obviously not in his place: political analyst 28/06/2019 17:11 Armenia’s authorities cannot have their candidate at Artsakh elections: NA speaker 28/06/2019 16:40 No issue of replacing CC chairman Hrayr Tovmasyan may be put theoretically: NA speaker 28/06/2019 16:11 Armenia returned Azerbaijani citizen without any pre-conditions: MFA spokesperson 28/06/2019 15:47 Ruling faction changes decision of having separate law on vetting: Makunts 28/06/2019 15:34 Discussions necessary to solve the crisis over Constitutional Court: NA speaker 28/06/2019 14:58 Constitutional Court works and to continue work normally: CC issues a statement 28/06/2019 14:45 Armenian citizen appeared in Azerbaijani territory in 2017 repatriated 28/06/2019 14:16 Life does not stop and changes are always possible: YSU acting rector 28/06/2019 13:53 DR Congo copper and cobalt miners killed in Kolwezi 28/06/2019 13:19 Manvel Grigoryan kept in custody on purpose: lawyer 28/06/2019 12:53 Artsakh’s former FM appointed special assignment envoy of Armenia’s PM 28/06/2019 12:42 Ex-lawmaker Manvel Grigoryan’s son charged 28/06/2019 12:23 Trump to Putin: Please don't meddle in U.S. elections 28/06/2019 11:43 European heatwave: Temperature may pass highest on record in France 28/06/2019 11:06 Heavy hail harms fields and gardens in Martuni (video) 28/06/2019 10:59 President signs amendments into tax legislation while being on official visit to Geneva: Mane Tandilyan 28/06/2019 10:43 iPhone designer Jony Ive to leave Apple 27/06/2019 21:15 Minimal salary should reach 110,000 AMD not 68,000 set by government: economist 27/06/2019 17:02 Two suicide attacks hit Tunisia's capital 27/06/2019 16:29 Venezuela crisis: Maduro says 'fascist' coup foiled 27/06/2019 15:43 Armenia, Russia may have different perceptions of issues, but discussions solve the issues: Armenia’s FM 27/06/2019 15:31 Language of threat not to work in Armenia's case: Foreign Minister 27/06/2019 15:04 Dushanbe must become Dushanbe plus: Mnatsakanyan says reality shows parties sometimes choose wrong path 27/06/2019 14:12 Armenia, Malta to boost political dialogue 27/06/2019 14:00 Negotiations over formation of Russian gas price continue: PSRC chairman 27/06/2019 13:42 Revolution reached Armenia’s regions: Syunik governor 27/06/2019 13:26 Trump and Putin to meet in Osaka on Friday 27/06/2019 13:00 Contracts on purchase and supply of new generation weaponry signed in sidelines of Armiya-2019 event in Russian 27/06/2019 12:30 Government approves bill on raising minimal salaries 27/06/2019 11:46 Armenia’s economy continues registering growth: Prime Minister 27/06/2019 11:35 Concrete arrangements reached with Russian PM Medvedev on export issues